Review: “Singing in the Wilderness” Thrusts A Miao Church Choir Into the Spotlight

"Singing in the Wilderness" documents a rare story of a Christian choir from China's Miao ethnic minority.

By , 28 Jan 22 00:29 GMT
Courtesy of Tail Bite Tail Films.

The documentary Singing in the Wilderness is a look at a church chorus thrust into China’s national stage after fame from participating in a televised singing competition. What makes this chorus especially interesting is that all its members are Miao—one of China’s officially recognized ethnic minorities. Unlike the Muslim Uyghurs and Hui or Buddhist Tibetans, the Miao receive little international focus, which makes this documentary especially notable.

Although members of the church chorus start of singing hymns primarily for worship, stardom makes them frame their art in more materialistic dimensions. Money made from singing can be a way to afford new homes or to try and find a way out of rural poverty.

Singing in the Wilderness adopts a sympathetic perspective to its subjects, never shying away from the complexities faced by church members as they navigate touring China, learn to sing unfamiliar songs, and even travel to America to perform. Nor does the film shy away from taking an unflinching glimpse at the commodification of Miao culture due to tourism or through of televised programs featuring “ethnic minority” cultures. Director Chen Dongnan manages an admirable sensitivity to such issues, while being attentive to the agency of her subjects. 

Courtesy of Tail Bite Tail Films.

If Singing in the Wilderness does have a weak point, it is that it perhaps does not manage a close enough glimpse at its subjects. Though the documentary focuses to a larger extent on a newly married couple, the husband of whom hopes to become a preacher, the shifts in the lives of this couple come without warning. One has little sense of the inner turmoil of the husband, for example, before captions inform the viewer that he attempted to kill himself. One also has little sense of the impending split facing the couple before it happens. 

There also is not any clear ending point for the documentary, with the film taking its leave of its subjects after a certain point. This, too, is a bit abrupt. Perhaps one should not blame a documentary for failing to look deeply enough into the lives of its subjects, but the film does its best, critically capturing an engrossing subject and doing so with a humanistic lens. 

Singing in the Wilderness (Chinese: 旷野歌声)—China. Dialog in Mandarin Chinese. Directed by Chen Dongnan. Running time 1hr 38min. First screened at the Thessaloniki Documentary Festival on 25 June, 2021. 

This article is part of Cinema Escapist‘s coverage of the 2022 International Film Festival Rotterdam.

This article was also published in No Man Is An Island, an online publication focused on the connections between everyday life and politics. No Man Is An Island is brought to you by the team behind New Bloom Magazine.

Want more? Join our 30K+ followers on Facebook and Twitter.

You May Also Like


Review: "The Best Is Yet to Come" Views China's Hepatitis B Discrimination Through An Auteur Lens

By Anthony Kao


Review: "The Old Town Girls" Uses Neo-Noir to Showcase Tragic Lives in China's Rust Belt

By Richard Yu


Interview: Director Zero Chou on Making LGBT Films in the Greater China Region

By The News Lens


Review: "Ash Is Purest White" Stands Stubbornly Still While China Moves Forward

By Anthony Kao